Sunday, May 9, 2010

Journal #3 - My Sister's Keeper

What are the consequences of decisions?

I have now finished my novel, "My Sister's Keeper", and I have also completed the novel "The Last Song". This week in class we focus on relationships and how they affect peoples decisions. In "My Sister's Keeper," it is hard for Anna to open up to her parents because of their common bond with Kate, once removed from that environment and moved to the fire house Anna felt a stronger connection with her dad because he wanted Anna to be comfortable. This allowed Anna to open up to her father more easily and it also made him a bigger influence in her decision. In "The Last Song," as Ronnie slowly opens up to her dad, their bond grows and her trust in him also grows. By the end she is telling him everything and making him her biggest influence. When she doesn't know what to do about Will, her father is the first person she goes to for advice, and usually she bases her final decision on what her father says she should do. As relationships grow, trust grows, and the ability to influences also grows.

The consequences of peoples decisions are always different because the decisions are always different. In Anna's case, if she decides to not donate her kidney (which in the end she does because she dies) then Kate would die. While in "The Last Song" Ronnie's decision to stay and take care of her dad doesn't change the outcome of what will happen to him, no matter what he is going to pass away. The consequence of a decision is based on the decision its self and the person making it, each case is different therefore each consequence is different.

Monday, May 3, 2010

Journal #2 - My Sister's Keeper

How does the environment affect one's decisions?

I have now finished the novel, My Sister's Keeper. Anna won the law suit but on the way to the hospital got into a car accident and suffered brain damage. She was dying so her lawyer, Campbell decided it was best to donate her kidney to her sister Kate.

The environment affects one's decisions greatly. The calmer the environment, the easier it is to make a decision, while the more stressful an environment the harder it is to make a decision. Time is also a factor, in My Sister's Keeper, Anna is forced to make many decisions, the first is one we don't know about until the end of the book. Anna has to decide whether to listen to her sister's wish and stop being a donor and let her die, or do what she knows is best. I think that for Anna, this decision was one of the hardest. Depending on the time and the place, Anna kept changing her mind, she never knew if what she was doing was the right thing. When she was with her mom, who was urging her not to do it, she thought that it was the wrong decision and almost wanted to change her mind. While when she was with Campbell in his office or where she felt safe, it was easy for her to say that she wanted medical emancipation. Setting was big for Anna and helped her realize that she really didn't want to hurt anyone, she just wanted to do what her sister asked.

I can connect to this because sometimes, even if I know that it is wrong, I will do anything for my sister because I love her and we are always meant to be there for each other. I think that my sister influences my decisions more than my parents because she is closer to my age and I know that she will always be there to have my back. I also think that I am a person who lets her parents influence her a lot as well. While around one parent I may think one way, but around the other I may think something different just because of their views and outlook on life. I think this it what makes me, I am something in between. My decisions are based on my setting and the people in my surroundings, but because they are different, so am I, I'm a mix of them both.